Existing on Erasure’s Edge

BIPOC Treatment in Peer Review

Authors

Keywords:

peer review, scholarly publishing, BIPOC scholars, library and information science

Abstract

The authors of this research are Black women employed in higher education academic libraries with expectations to actively participate in the scholarly community as researchers, writers, presenters, reviewers, and editors. After multiple personal and observed experiences receiving thinly veiled and outright biased feedback from reviewers and editors in supposedly anonymous review processes, the authors decided to channel our frustration into an exploratory study that queries if our experiences are shared amongst the BIPOC library and information studies (LIS) scholarly community. This study explores how implicit and explicit bias impacts BIPOC scholars in LIS from both the writers’ and reviewers perspectives. While this study purposefully centers BIPOC experiences, the participant pool includes people of White and/or European descent to infer how bias impacts decision making (e.g, accept, reject, revise and resubmit) and the feedback BIPOC writers experience throughout navigating the LIS peer review process. We found that the peer review process was clearly marked with unnecessary hassles including: time constraints, transactional reviews, and bias.  Although the time constraints and transactional reviews didn’t stop scholars from resubmitting to other journals, those experiences have made them reflect on the processes that journals take prior to submission. Alternatively, negative interactions that were rooted in racial and gender bias made those scholars question submission to another peer-review publication in perpetuity.

Author Biographies

V. Dozier, University of San Diego

V. Dozier is an Associate Professor, the Education Librarian, and Coordinator of Graduate Student Programs for the University of San Diego’s Copley Library. Her research interests include how people with marginalized identities experience/perceive higher education spaces (e.g., academic libraries), DEIA, and graphic novel use in academic environments.

Amanda M. Leftwich, Montgomery County Community College

Amanda M. Leftwich is the Student Success Librarian for Montgomery County Community College’s Brelindger Library. Her research interests include communities of practices in academia, mindful practice in librarianship and information sciences, DEIA, and wellness for BIPOC scholars.

Downloads

Published

2023-11-29

Issue

Section

Research Articles